Arrowhead Mills Creamy Peanut Butter
Roll Over Image to Magnify
& Click to Zoom
Save 10% and Get Automatic Delivery with Set & Save

Why Set & Save?

  • Extra 10% off Bonus Brands
  • Schedule delivery according to YOUR needs
  • Lock in the guaranteed lowest prices
  • Surprise gifts & more
  • Never run out of your favorite items
  • Change or cancel at any time

Just click "Add to Set & Save" when placing items in your cart.

Enjoy our low price guarantee, plus an additional 10% off with Set & Save!
Arrowhead Mills Creamy Peanut Butter -- 26 oz
Item #: ARR 3470441
SKU #: 074333470441
Count: 26 oz
Weight: 2.56 lb
Serving: 2 Tbsp. (32 g)
Servings: 23

Nutrition Facts
Serving Size: 2 Tbsp. (32 g)
Servings per Container: 23
Amount Per Serving% Daily Value
   Calories from Fat150*
Total Fat17 g25%
   Saturated Fat2.5 g13%
   Trans Fat0 g*
Cholesterol0 mg0%
Sodium0 mg0%
Total Carbohydrate6 g2%
   Dietary Fiber2 g9%
   Sugars1 g
Protein8 g10%
Vitamin A0%
Vitamin C0%
*Daily value not established.
Other Ingredients: Dry roasted peanuts
Contains: Peanuts. May contain traces of soy and tree nuts.

Arrowhead Mills Creamy Peanut Butter Description

  • 100% Valencia Peanuts
  • No Salt Added
  • 8g Protein Per Serving
  • Gluten Free Food
  • All Natural
  • 0g Trans Fat
  • Good Source of Protein
  • No Oils or Stabilizers Added
  • Oil separation is natural with this product


Refrigerate after opening.

Free Of
Gluten, added salt, added oils or stabilizers.
These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.
Arrowhead Mills Creamy Peanut Butter -- 26 oz 3.8 5 5 5
top shelf... yes, this is the good stuff. if you're fan of peanuts and things that are real, you're going to love this... the smaller jars are good too but you may as well get a big jar because you're going to go through this stuff much faster than you will other brands of peanut butter because the flavor is addicting. i think a lot of it has to do with the variety of nuts they claim to use, valencia. although i admit it's starting to taste more like regular peanuts to me than it used to, it is still vastly superior to any other peanut butter that i have tried and i've tried quite a few brands over the years... mix this with some organic raw honey and some toasted organic whole grain bread and you've got a peanut butter sandwich worthy of a fine restaurant experience... November 15, 2013
have you ever eaten runny peanut butter ? Well I have , I don't know how they did it , w/o using more oil or h2o taste was fine. but for the $$$ not a good bargain. April 20, 2013
Great job Arrowhead Mills! This peanut butter has a smooth consistency and a great flavor. It's quite different from the supermarket brands, and although I was used to those flavors, I'm glad to change and avoid all the extra salt and other additives. Great job Arrowhead Mills! November 9, 2012
Don't like the flavor A+ for the right ingredients. D for flavor. Neither my parents, who were visiting, nor I liked the flavor. In fact, they went out to buy more peanut butter rather than eat this. I like several brands of natural peanut butter just fine but not this one. Santa Cruz Dark Roasted peanut butter is by far the best, but I had hoped to find a cheaper organic peanut butter. Now I'm just antsy for vitacost to bring Santa Cruz back! I'll pick up some sort of pb from the grocery store to tide me over.... September 10, 2012
Always dependable This is the best price that I have found anywhere for this product. I always receive the product quickly and in excellent condition. They even take the time to wrap each glass jar in bubble wrap. May 13, 2012
1-5 of 5
Know someone who would love this product? Don’t keep it a secret – share it now!
Note: Your friend's email address is used for this one-time notification only. We will not collect or store or share it with any other parties.
Friend's Name:
Your Name:
Friend's Email:
Your Email:
Message to your friend: (optional, max 500 characters)
Change the CAPTCHA codeSpeak the CAPTCHA code
Enter the code exactly as shown: 
You Save: 19%
Retail price: $11.89
Vitacost price: $9.52
Out of stock

Frequently Bought Together:
Arrowhead Mills Creamy Peanut Butter
Vitacost Extra Virgin Certified Organic Coconut Oil
Retail price together: $33.88
Vitacost price: $31.51
You Save: 6%

View details for Vitacost Extra Virgin Certified Organic Coconut Oil
People Who Viewed This Item Also Viewed
Arrowhead Mills Creamy Organic Peanut Butter
18% off
Retail price: $8.89
Vitacost price: $7.25
Arrowhead Mills Crunchy Organic Peanut Butter
18% off
Retail price: $8.89
Vitacost price: $7.25
Santa Cruz Organic Peanut Butter Dark Roasted Creamy
16% off
Retail price: $7.39
Vitacost price: $6.19
MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter Salted Creamy and Roasted
23% off
Retail price: $14.19
Vitacost price: $10.89
Earth Balance Peanut Butter Creamy
15% off
Retail price: $6.49
Vitacost price: $5.49