Beauty Without Cruelty Waterproof Mascara Black -- 0.27 fl oz
I really wanted to love this product. The company makes great products otherwise, and I love to try out different makeup lines. This mascara unfortunately is NOT waterproof nor smudgeproof. I only wear mascara on my upper lashes, and would have smudging under my eyes in a few hours. I had to put a second layer of waterproof mascara for assurance, will not be buying this again.
December 21, 2013
Results: sticky, clumpy, not much longer eyelashes
I was thrilled to find waterproof healthy mascara. I was frustrated and somewhat dumbfounded by how poorly it works! It doesn't seem like there is an adequate amount of the mascara in the tube. Plus, it causes my eyelashes to clump and scarcely lengthens them!
Really, quite atrocious. I recommend not wasting your time.
Hopefully, in the years ahead, BWC will make this product infinitely better.
November 8, 2013
I'm Sold ;)
Worked better than I thought. Didn't clump, smuge or flake away on me and it didn't make my eyes water. I have sensitive eyes.
August 13, 2013
Wasn't happy with this mascara
Every time I wore this mascara it would leave smudges under my eyes. I also found it nearly impossible to take off. The only thing that worked for me to take it off was jojoba oil. I would not recommend this mascara.
January 12, 2013
Runs instantly, really does not deliver
I was very disappointed by this mascara. I am committed to replace slowly and as needed all my beauty products to more eco-friendly ones. I disliked this mascara the first time I used it but gave it a couple of tries. In my case it immediately melted unto my lower lids with my own face oils. There was nothing "proof" about it. I also noticed that it clumped both on my eyes and out of the tube.
Vitacost was very good about crediting my account for the purchase once I e-mailed them with the problem. I hope they will soon start carrying Tarte cosmetics, as I found their eco-friendly waterproof mascara to be without compare, standing up to the best synthetic formulas.
July 2, 2012