skip to main content

ANNIVERSARY EVENT | 20% OFF SITEWIDE

Quick Reorder
Promo Pocket
Email Sign Up

Deliver to 43085
We are having technical difficulties.

Please try again or check back with us shortly.
Update your location

Availability of products may vary by location.

Shipping to:
- Country:
- *Zip/Post Code:

Get $20 in VITACASH when you spend $120

Your web browser's JavaScript doesn't seem to be enabled. To improve your shopping experience, please turn it on.

Chocolate Cups

Sorry, the product you're searching for is no longer available.
Based on your search, our Product Specialists suggest the following items:

Showing Products 1-35 of 35

Sort By

- 2 Flavors
Justin's Organic Mini Peanut Butter Cups Dark Chocolate -- 4.7 oz
(167)
$6.49
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Justin's Organic Mini Peanut Butter Cups Milk Chocolate -- 4.7 oz
(44)
$6.39
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Unreal Peanut Butter Cups Vegan Dark Chocolate -- 4.2 oz
(102)
$7.04
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Sun Cups with SunButter Gluten & Dairy Free Dark Chocolate -- 2 Cups
(47)
$2.29
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Unreal Almond Butter Cups Candy Vegan Gluten Free Dark Chocolate -- 3.2 oz
(51)
$6.49
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Chocolove Non-GMO Almond Butter Cups Dark Chocolate 55% -- 1.2 oz
(4)
$1.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Sunflower Butter Cups Chocolate -- 2 Cups
(49)
$2.29
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Justin's Peanut Butter Cups Super Dark Chocolate -- 4.2 oz
(9)
$6.39
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Sunflower Butter Mini Sun Cups Dark Chocolate -- 4.2 oz
(14)
$5.29
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Dark Chocolate Cups Mini Mint -- 3.5 oz
$5.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Chocolove Non-GMO Peanut Butter Cups Dark Chocolate 55% -- 1.2 oz
(1)
$2.09
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Dark Chocolate Cups Mini Sea Salt Caramel -- 3.5 oz
(1)
$5.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
SkinnyDipped Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups -- 3.17 oz
(132)
$5.79

$1.93 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Free2b Sun Cups Minis Gluten Free Vegan Chocolate -- 4.2 oz
(7)
$6.09
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code GFREE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Lakanto Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups No Sugar Added -- 3.17 oz
(138)
$7.88

$2.63 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 4CF10 to save 10%
Add to Cart
Justin's Almond Butter Cups Super Dark Chocolate Espresso -- 4.2 oz
(9)
$6.29
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Theo Almond Butter Cups 55% Dark Chocolate Organic -- 1.3 oz
(5)
$2.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Justin's Peanut Butter Cups Milk Chocolate -- 12 Two-Cup Packages
(11)
$27.44
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Justin's Peanut Butter Cups Dark Chocolate -- 12 Two-Cup Packages
(29)
$26.39
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Justin's Organic Dark Chocolate Almond Butter Cups -- 1.4 oz Each / Pack of 12
(5)
$26.71
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
SkinnyDipped Caramel Peanut Paradise Cup -- 3.17 oz
(3)
$5.69
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Justin's Cashew Butter Cup Dark Chocolate -- 1.4 oz Each / Pack of 12
(3)
$26.09
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Justin's Organic Crispy Peanut Butter Cup Caddy Dark Chocolate -- 15.84
(2)
$22.31
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
SkinnyDipped Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups -- 3.17 oz
(3)
$6.49

$2.17 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Add to Cart
Lily's Milk Chocolate Style Peanut Butter Cups - 2 Cups -- 1.25 oz
(19)
$2.19
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15ALLLILYS to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
Lily's 70% Cacao Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Bar -- 1.25 oz
(1)
$2.19
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15ALLLILYS to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
- 2 Sizes
Theo Organic Peanut Butter Cups Dark Chocolate -- 1.3 oz
(26)
$2.79
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
Reese's Plant Based Oat Chocolate Peanut Butter Miniatures Cups Pouch -- 4.5 oz
(66)
$5.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
Reese's Zero Sugar Dark Chocolate & Peanut Butter Cup Miniatures Pouch -- 5.1 oz
(6)
$5.99
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved Keto Cups Almond Butter -- 4.93 oz
(15)
$9.09

$1.30 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved Organic Dark Chocolate Cups Hazelnut -- 4.93 oz
(42)
$8.49

$1.22 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved Organic Dark Chocolate Keto Cups Coconut -- 4.93 oz
(27)
$9.19

$1.32 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved White Chocolate Keto Cup Organic Brownie Batter -- 4.93 oz
(4)
$9.29

$1.33 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved Dark Chocolate Keto Cups Organic Hazelnut Butter -- 2 Cups
(4)
$2.59

$1.30 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items
EatingEvolved Dark Chocolate Keto Cups Organic Coconut Butter -- 2 Cups
(3)
$2.39

$1.20 per serving
- Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
- Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items

Back to Top

QR Code to download the mobile app

Sign Up & Save

Get exclusive offers, free shipping events, expert health tips & more by signing up for our promotional emails.

Enter your email address

Instant Online Service
Chat with us
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday-Sunday 9:30am-6pm EST
1-800-381-0759
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday: 9:30am-6pm EST

Sunday: Closed
Email us anytime

USA Today Americas Customer Service Champions 20204

Copyright © 2025 Vitacost.com. All rights reserved • Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.

Enter Shipping Zip Code:
Please enter a valid zip code

FLDC1