skip to main content

BEAUTY WEEK: 20% OFF + STACKABLE DEALS

Quick Reorder
Promo Pocket
Email Sign Up

Deliver to 43085
We are having technical difficulties.

Please try again or check back with us shortly.
Update your location

Availability of products may vary by location.

Shipping to:
- Country:
- *Zip/Post Code:

Your web browser's JavaScript doesn't seem to be enabled. To improve your shopping experience, please turn it on.

Peanut Butter Alternatives

Sorry, the product you're searching for is no longer available.
Based on your search, our Product Specialists suggest the following items:

Showing Products 1-36 of 36

Sort By

Vitacost Gluten Free Almond Butter Smooth Unsalted -- 16 oz
(653)
$8.19
Add to Cart
Once Again Almond Butter Unsweetened & Roasted Crunchy -- 16 oz
(219)
$11.05
Add to Cart
SunButter Natural Sunflower Spread No Sugar Added -- 16 oz
(16)
$7.29
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz
(140)
$15.61
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 24 oz
(10)
$12.99
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Pecan Nut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz
(77)
$14.10
Add to Cart
Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Smooth -- 16 oz
(41)
$12.49
Add to Cart
Once Again Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter -- 16 oz
(64)
$8.60
Add to Cart
- 9 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Gluten Free Peanut Butter The Bee's Knees -- 16 oz
(87)
$4.99
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews Squeeze Pack -- 1 Packet
(26)
$3.24
Add to Cart
PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter -- 24 oz
(13)
$14.18
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 6.5 oz
(2)
$4.99
Add to Cart
WowButter Nut-Free All Natural Peanut Butter Soy Spread Creamy -- 17.6 oz
(27)
$7.18
Add to Cart
Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Crunchy -- 10 oz
(19)
$8.79
Add to Cart
Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder -- 24 oz
(2)
$13.19
Add to Cart
Walden Farms Calorie Free Whipped Peanut Spread -- 12 oz
(152)
$4.79
Add to Cart
Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter -- 6.35 oz
(48)
$9.99

$0.67 per serving
Add to Cart
Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Chocolate -- 6.43 oz
(12)
$10.19
Add to Cart
Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder Sugar Free -- 7 oz
(5)
$5.99
Add to Cart
PB2 Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 6.5 oz
(2)
$7.18
Add to Cart
- 2 Sizes
PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter -- 16 oz
(166)
$12.39
Add to Cart
- 3 Flavors
Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Cookie Dough -- 12 oz
(1)
$8.70
Add to Cart
PB2 Peanut Powder with Cocoa -- 16 oz
(53)
$11.54
Add to Cart
- 3 Flavors
Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Original -- 12 oz
(1)
$8.59
Add to Cart
- 3 Flavors
Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Vanilla -- 12 oz
(2)
$8.60
Add to Cart
Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder -- 8 oz
(2)
$7.39
Add to Cart
Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Protein Spread - Smooth -- 16 oz
$10.09

$0.73 per serving
Add to Cart
PB2 Peanut Powder with Pre + Probiotics Original -- 6.5 oz
(1)
$8.05

$0.58 per serving
Add to Cart
- 2 Sizes
PB2 The Original PB2 Crunchy Powdered Peanut Butter -- 6.5 oz
(27)
$6.32

$0.46 per serving
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Vanilla -- 6.5 oz
(14)
$6.49
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Pure Peanut -- 6.5 oz
(9)
$6.49
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Flax & Chia -- 6.5 oz
(14)
$6.49
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Original -- 6.5 oz
(14)
$6.49
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Cocoa -- 6.5 oz
(10)
$6.49
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Honey -- 6.5 oz
(7)
$6.49
Add to Cart
Voyage Foods Roasted Seed Spread Top 9 Allergen Free Non GMO Peanut-Free Spread Peanut -- 16 oz
$5.71
Temporarily unavailable
View similar items

Back to Top

QR Code to download the mobile app

Sign Up & Save

Get exclusive offers, free shipping events, expert health tips & more by signing up for our promotional emails.

Enter your email address

Instant Online Service
Chat with us
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday-Sunday 9:30am-6pm EST
1-800-381-0759
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday: 9:30am-6pm EST

Sunday: Closed
Email us anytime

USA Today Americas Customer Service Champions 20204

Copyright © 2025 Vitacost.com. All rights reserved • Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.

Enter Shipping Zip Code:
Please enter a valid zip code

FLDC9