skip to main content
ANNIVERSARY EVENT | 20% OFF SITEWIDE
  • Quick Reorder
  • Promo Pocket
  • Email Sign Up
  • Deliver to 43085

    Update your location

    Availability of products may vary by location.

    Shipping to:




Get $20 in VITACASH when you spend $120
Brand
Price
Rating
Specialties
Form
Servings
Flavor
Availability

Peanut Butter Alternatives

Sorry, the product you're searching for is no longer available.
Based on your search, our Product Specialists suggest the following items:

Showing Products 1-53 of 53
Sort By
Go Go
    Vitacost Gluten Free Almond Butter Smooth Unsalted

    Vitacost Gluten Free Almond Butter Smooth Unsalted -- 16 oz

    (653)

    $8.19

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Buy one get one 50% off
    Add to Cart
    Once Again Almond Butter Unsweetened & Roasted Crunchy

    Once Again Almond Butter Unsweetened & Roasted Crunchy -- 16 oz

    (219)

    $11.05

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    SunButter Natural Sunflower Spread No Sugar Added

    SunButter Natural Sunflower Spread No Sugar Added -- 16 oz

    (16)

    $7.29

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original

    Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 24 oz

    (10)

    $12.99

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Buy one get one 50% off
    Add to Cart
    Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews

    Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz

    (140)

    $15.61

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Artisana Organic Raw Pecan Nut Butter with Cashews

    Artisana Organic Raw Pecan Nut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz

    (77)

    $14.10

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Smooth

    Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Smooth -- 16 oz

    (41)

    $12.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Once Again Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter

    Once Again Creamy Sunflower Seed Butter -- 16 oz

    (64)

    $8.60

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Gluten Free Peanut Butter The Bee's Knees

    Peanut Butter & Co Gluten Free Peanut Butter The Bee's Knees -- 16 oz

    (88)

    $4.99

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original

    Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 6.5 oz

    (3)

    $4.99

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Buy one get one 50% off
    Add to Cart
    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter

    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter -- 24 oz

    (13)

    $14.18

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews Squeeze Pack

    Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews Squeeze Pack -- 1 Packet

    (26)

    $3.24

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    WowButter Nut-Free All Natural Peanut Butter Soy Spread Creamy

    WowButter Nut-Free All Natural Peanut Butter Soy Spread Creamy -- 17.6 oz

    (27)

    $7.18

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Crunchy

    Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Crunchy -- 10 oz

    (19)

    $8.79

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    • Use code 15BEVSFOOD to save 15%
    Add to Cart
    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder

    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder -- 24 oz

    (2)

    $13.19

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Walden Farms Calorie Free Whipped Peanut Spread

    Walden Farms Calorie Free Whipped Peanut Spread -- 12 oz

    (152)

    $4.79

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter

    Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter -- 6.35 oz

    (48)

    $9.99

    $0.67 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder Sugar Free

    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder Sugar Free -- 7 oz

    (5)

    $5.99

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Chocolate

    Betty Lou's Non-GMO Just Great Stuff Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Chocolate -- 6.43 oz

    (12)

    $10.19

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    PB2 Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original

    PB2 Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 6.5 oz

    (2)

    $7.18

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter

    PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter -- 16 oz

    (166)

    $12.39

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Original

    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Original -- 12 oz

    (1)

    $8.59

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Cookie Dough

    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Cookie Dough -- 12 oz

    (1)

    $8.70

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    PB2 Peanut Powder with Cocoa

    PB2 Peanut Powder with Cocoa -- 16 oz

    (53)

    $11.54

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Vanilla

    Oat Haus Organic Nut Free Granola Butter Vanilla -- 12 oz

    (2)

    $8.60

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder

    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Powder -- 8 oz

    (2)

    $7.39

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Rory's Cookie Monster Madness

    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Rory's Cookie Monster Madness -- 16 oz

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Protein Spread - Smooth

    Better Body Foods Non-GMO PB Fit Peanut Butter Protein Spread - Smooth -- 16 oz

    $10.09

    $0.73 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    PB2 Peanut Powder with Pre + Probiotics Original

    PB2 Peanut Powder with Pre + Probiotics Original -- 6.5 oz

    (1)

    $8.05

    $0.58 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    PB2 The Original PB2 Crunchy Powdered Peanut Butter

    PB2 The Original PB2 Crunchy Powdered Peanut Butter -- 6.5 oz

    (27)

    $6.32

    $0.46 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Brookie Cashew Butter

    Fit Butters Brookie Cashew Butter -- 16 oz

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough -- 16 oz

    (1)

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Salted Caramel Pretzel

    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Salted Caramel Pretzel -- 16 oz

    $13.29

    $0.95 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Scotcheroo

    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Scotcheroo -- 16 oz

    $13.19

    $0.95 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Monster Cookie

    Fit Butters Peanut Butter Monster Cookie -- 16 oz

    $12.99

    $0.93 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Caramel Fudge Coconut Cookie -- 16 oz

    $12.99

    $0.93 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup -- 16 oz

    $12.99

    $0.93 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Banana Maple French Toast

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Banana Maple French Toast -- 16 oz

    $14.29

    $1.03 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Peanut Butter S'Mores

    Fit Butters Peanut Butter S'Mores -- 16 oz

    $14.39

    $1.03 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Charley's Famous Carrot Cake

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Charley's Famous Carrot Cake -- 16 oz

    $13.79

    $0.99 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Cinnamon Sugar Cookie

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Cinnamon Sugar Cookie -- 16 oz

    (4)

    $12.99

    $0.93 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Vanilla

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Vanilla -- 6.5 oz

    (14)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Chocolate Caramel Crunch Bar

    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Chocolate Caramel Crunch Bar -- 16 oz

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Birthday Cake

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Birthday Cake -- 16 oz

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Pure Peanut

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Pure Peanut -- 6.5 oz

    (9)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Cookie Butter

    Fit Butters Cashew Almond Butter Vegan Cookie Butter -- 16 oz

    $13.39

    $0.96 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Cocoa Pebbles

    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Cocoa Pebbles -- 16 oz

    $14.99

    $1.08 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Fruity Pebbles

    Fit Butters Cashew Butter Fruity Pebbles -- 16 oz

    $14.99

    $1.08 per serving

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Cocoa

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Cocoa -- 6.5 oz

    (10)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Original

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Original -- 6.5 oz

    (14)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Flax & Chia

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Flax & Chia -- 6.5 oz

    (14)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Honey

    Peanut Butter & Co Vegan Gluten Free Peanut Powder Honey -- 6.5 oz

    (7)

    $6.49

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%
    Add to Cart
    Voyage Foods Roasted Seed Spread Top 9 Allergen Free Non GMO Peanut-Free Spread Peanut

    Voyage Foods Roasted Seed Spread Top 9 Allergen Free Non GMO Peanut-Free Spread Peanut -- 16 oz

    $5.71

    • Use code CELEBRATE20 to save 20%

    Temporarily unavailable

    View similar items
Sign Up & Save

Get exclusive offers, free shipping events, expert health tips & more by signing up for our promotional emails.

USA Today Americas Customer Service Champions 20204

Copyright © 2025 Vitacost.com. All rights reserved • Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.

Please enter a valid zip code
FLDC7