skip to main content

FOURTH OF JULY SALE: UP TO 15% OFF

Quick Reorder
Promo Pocket
Email Sign Up

Deliver to 43085
We are having technical difficulties.

Please try again or check back with us shortly.
Update your location

Availability of products may vary by location.

Shipping to:
- Country:
- *Zip/Post Code:

Your web browser's JavaScript doesn't seem to be enabled. To improve your shopping experience, please turn it on.

Nut Butters, Jams & Jellies

Sorry, the product you're searching for is no longer available.
Based on your search, our Product Specialists suggest the following items:

Showing Products 1-60 of 361

Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next

Show 60

Sort By

Santa Cruz Organic Crunchy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter -- 16 oz
(119)
$7.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Vitacost Certified Organic Non-GMO Peanut Butter Smooth Unsalted -- 18 oz
(420)
$5.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter -- 16 oz
(94)
$7.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Vitacost Certified Organic Non-GMO Peanut Butter Crunchy Salted -- 18 oz
(242)
$5.99

$0.38 per serving
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Vitacost Gluten Free Almond Butter Smooth Unsalted -- 16 oz
(656)
$8.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- Top Seller
Artisana Organic Raw Almond Butter -- 14 oz
(163)
$17.68
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Vitacost Certified Organic Non-GMO Peanut Butter Smooth Salted -- 18 oz
(151)
$5.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Organic Peanut Butter Creamy Unsweetened Salt Free -- 16 oz
(154)
$8.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Tahini Pure Ground Sesame Seed -- 16 oz
(38)
$6.49
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Sunflower Seed Butter Creamy Unsweetened -- 16 oz
(235)
$7.79
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Crofters Organic Fruit Spread Strawberry -- 10 oz
(120)
$4.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 2 Flavors
Vitacost Certified Organic Non-GMO Peanut Butter Crunchy Unsalted -- 18 oz
(163)
$5.99

$0.38 per serving
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Organic Peanut Butter Salt Free Crunchy -- 16 oz
(70)
$8.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Crazy Richard's Natural Peanut Butter 100% Peanuts Crunchy -- 16 oz
(73)
$3.29
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 12 Flavors
Rigoni di Asiago Fiordifrutta Organic Fruit Spread Strawberries & Wild Strawberries -- 8.82 oz
(85)
$8.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Smooth Almond Butter -- 16 oz
(19)
$6.79
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Woodstock Non-GMO Kosher Almond Butter Smooth Lightly Toasted -- 16 oz
(341)
$10.60
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Coconut Butter -- 14 oz
(179)
$12.08
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Almond Butter Crunchy -- 16 oz
(17)
$6.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Cashew Butter Raw Cashew -- 14 oz
(138)
$16.59
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
SunButter Organic Sunflower Butter -- 16 oz
(151)
$9.79
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Crofters Organic Fruit Spread Wild Blueberry -- 10 oz
(105)
$4.79
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Natural Creamy Almond Butter Unsweetened & Roasted -- 16 oz
(104)
$11.60
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Almond Butter Unsweetened & Roasted Crunchy -- 16 oz
(220)
$11.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Woodstock Non-GMO Organic Kosher Sesame Tahini Unsalted -- 16 oz
(49)
$9.88
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Cashew Butter Creamy Unsweetened -- 16 oz
(109)
$11.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Sunflower Butter -- 16 oz
(40)
$6.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Organic Unsweetened Tahini Creamy -- 16 oz
(124)
$10.29
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 4 Flavors
Bionaturae Organic Fruit Spread Bilberry -- 9 oz
(67)
$5.49
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Crofters Organic Fruit Spread Raspberry -- 10 oz
(96)
$5.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Rigoni di Asiago Nocciolata Organic Hazelnut Spread with Cocoa Dairy Free -- 8.82 oz
(7)
$7.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Tahini Sesame Seed Butter -- 14 oz
(114)
$11.66
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
SunButter Natural Sunflower Spread No Sugar Added -- 16 oz
(16)
$7.29
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Woodstock Non-GMO Almond Butter Smooth Unsalted -- 16 oz
(71)
$10.60
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 6 Flavors
Crofters Organic Fruit Spread Apricot -- 10 oz
(87)
$5.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Dastony Organic Sprouted Pumpkin Seed Butter -- 16 oz
(23)
$17.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter Spread -- 40 oz
(24)
$10.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic No Stir Creamy Peanut Butter Spread -- 16 oz
(72)
$5.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Creamy Peanut Butter -- 15 oz
(42)
$5.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 4 Flavors
Simple Truth Organic Fruit Spread Four Fruits -- 16.5 oz
(37)
$4.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
MaraNatha Natural Raw Almond Butter Creamy -- 16 oz
(108)
$13.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Powdered Peanut Butter Original -- 24 oz
(10)
$12.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Crofters Organic Fruit Spread Strawberry -- 16.5 oz
(95)
$6.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Eden Foods Organic Apple Butter Spread -- 17 oz
(110)
$11.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 4 Flavors
Bionaturae Organic Fruit Spread Apricot -- 9 oz
(42)
$5.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Gopal's Organic Sprouted Walnut Butter Creamy Unsalted -- 8 oz
(20)
$16.49

$2.07 per serving
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Walnut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz
(140)
$14.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 12 Flavors
Rigoni di Asiago Fiordifrutta Organic Fruit Spread Raspberry -- 8.82 oz
(45)
$5.89
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Once Again Organic Peanut Butter Creamy American Classic -- 16 oz
(36)
$8.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 4 Flavors
Simple Truth Organic Fruit Spread Strawberry -- 16.5 oz
(21)
$4.49
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter -- 15 oz
(14)
$4.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Soom Premium Tahini -- 11 oz
(2)
$7.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter Creamy -- 16 oz
(46)
$6.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 12 Flavors
Rigoni di Asiago Fiordifrutta Organic Fruit Spread Wild Berries -- 8.82 oz
(36)
$6.19
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Crazy Richard's Kosher Peanut Butter Creamy -- 16 oz
(110)
$4.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Simple Truth Organic No Stir Crunchy Peanut Butter Spread -- 16 oz
(29)
$5.09
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 12 Flavors
Rigoni di Asiago Fiordifrutta Organic Fruit Spread Peach -- 8.82 oz
(35)
$5.69
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
- 12 Flavors
Rigoni di Asiago Fiordifrutta Organic Fruit Spread Apricot -- 8.82 oz
(74)
$6.49
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Barney Butter Non-GMO Almond Butter Bare Smooth -- 16 oz
(41)
$11.99
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart
Artisana Organic Raw Pecan Nut Butter with Cashews -- 8 oz
(77)
$13.39
- Use code FOURTH to save 15%
Add to Cart

Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Next

Back to Top

QR Code to download the mobile app

Sign Up & Save

Get exclusive offers, free shipping events, expert health tips & more by signing up for our promotional emails.

Enter your email address

Instant Online Service
Chat with us
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday-Sunday 9:30am-6pm EST
1-800-381-0759
Monday-Friday 8am-9pm EST

Saturday: 9:30am-6pm EST

Sunday: Closed
Email us anytime

USA Today Americas Customer Service Champions 20204

Copyright © 2025 Vitacost.com. All rights reserved • Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners.

Enter Shipping Zip Code:
Please enter a valid zip code

LVDC15